2009 Cleveland Browns Preview
The 2009 Cleveland Browns will take the field with a much different attitude than the 2008 team. The days of club Crennel are over as the Browns were pushed to the limit during training camp under the non nonsense approach of new head coach Eric Mangini. Mangini immediately set the tone as traded malcontent Kellen Winslow to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers prior to the draft. There were rumors he was going to do the same with boisterous Braylon Edwards. Edwards remains with the team but Mangini drafted two touted receivers in the draft, Brian Robiskie and Mohamed Massaquoi. In addition, the Browns signed two crafty veterans in Mike Furrey and David Patten. Win or lose, the Browns will play smart and hard under Man-Genius.
Quarterback: Heading into the season the QB battle continues between former All-Pro Derek Anderson and Ohio native and beloved son Brady Quinn. Anderson had a very good 2007 but was victim to questionable decisions and proved to be shaky when under pressure at the end of the 07 season. Although he led the Browns to a 10-6 record, he fell apart in a must win against lowly Cincinnati in a game that would have propelled the team into the playoffs. In 2008, things only got worse. Anderson was shaky and his biggest weakness was on display as he only completed 50.2% of his passes. Brady Quinn’s performance in the 3rd preseason game should be enough to win the job. In 2008, Quinn played well in a tough loss to Denver and was effective against Buffalo until breaking a finger. Quinn has leadership qualities and control of the huddle that Anderson lacks. Anderson can throw the ball a mile but does not have the touch or ability to read a defense that Quinn has. In the end Quinn will win the position and get a chance to bring excitement to his beloved fans. The story reads of the Bernie Kosar era, Browns’ fans hope so. Rating: B
Running Back: The Browns still have 1,000 yard rusher Jamal Lewis. However, Lewis just turned 30 and seems to tap dance in the hole and lacks the quickness and explosion of his younger days. Lewis is still an effective goal line runner and will always run hard. Jerome Harrison was very effective but inexplicably didn’t receive the amount of carries he deserved. Harrison gained 246 yards on only 34 carries for a 7.2 average. The Browns drafted James Davis out of Clemson to help ease the load on Lewis. Davis played high school ball at the same school as Lewis. Lewis has taken the rookie under his wing stating Davis is very receptive to coaching and could be an effective runner in time. Fullback Lawrence Vicker is an effective blocker, short yardage runner and intermediate pass catcher. Rating: C+
Wide Receivers: Braylon Edwards had a tremendous 2007 catching 16 TD’s. In 2008, like most of the team, Edwards was full of himself and lacked focus. Edwards has the talent to be a top tier receiver and can dramatically affect the opposing defense’s coverage. Edwards was rumored to be traded but Mangini decided to hold on to the ultra talented receiver. Edwards is in a contract year so look for the 2007 Edwards to resurface. Mr. everything Josh Cribbs will compete for the 2nd receiver slot. Cribbs is one of the most versatile players in the league and will no doubt be effective as Edwards’ side kick. The Browns brought in Mike Furrey via free agency. In the preseason Furrey reminded Browns’ fans of another #88, Brian Brennan. Furrey, like Brennan, is a very good possession receiver and will be a valuable safety valve for Quinn. The Browns drafted polished route runner Brian Robiske and slick Mohamed Massaquoi. Each get significant time. Prior to the draft the Browns signed cagey veteran David Patten who will now struggle to make the team. After the shocking news that starter Donte Stallworth was involved in a drunk driving fatality, the receiver position looked like a weakness. Despite Stallworth being suspended, the receiver position is now one of the strengths of the team. Rating: B+
Tight End: Mangini quickly parted ways with former All-Pro Kellen Winslow trading him to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Winslow’s receiving abilities will sorely be missed but his lack of blocking and occasional blow ups may equate to addition by subtraction. The Browns added former Bill tight end Robert Royal. Royal is an effective blocker who will not make many catches. Steve Heiden is as tough as they come. He is already playing despite a torn ACL late in the season. Heiden will be a nice target for Quinn. Rating: B-
Offensive Line: The heart and soul of the line is All-Pro left tackle Joe Thomas. Critics didn’t feel Thomas was as effective as his rookie 2007 season. However, Thomas played very well despite the lack of stability on the rest of the line. Left guard Eric Steinbach is a very effective starter. He lacks the size that Mangini would like but uses his athleticism and technique to control his opponent. The center position is up for grabs as incumbent Hank Fraley battles rookie 1st round pick Alex Mack. Mack is the future of the team and will likely be the starter sooner than later. The right guard will be filled by Pork Chop Womack and the right tackle by John St. Clair. The team has depth on the offensive line with Rex Hadnot and Ryan Tucker. Rating: B+
Defensive Line: The defensive line is anchored by All-Pro behemoth Shaun Rodgers. The 350+lb Rogers crashes the pocket and is very good against the run. Robaire Smith returns from an injury and should compete for reps. Corey Williams returns after an injury marred 2008. The team added former Jets Kenyon Coleman and C.J. Mosely both of which are good against the run. As with the offensive line, this unit should be much improved and now has depth. Rating: B
Linebackers: The linebacker corp has been highly scrutinized throughout the Crennel era. They have not been effective in any capacity as they couldn’t generate a pass rush nor could tackle a running back in a phone booth. The only bright spot has been D’Qwell Jackson. Jackson led the league in tackles and gets better every season. The team finally parted ways with Andra Davis replacing him with solid veteran and former Jet Eric Barton. They also added former Jet David Bowens who should help against the run. The Browns drafted athletic linebackers David Veikune and Kaluka Maiava in the draft. Maiava is expected to be a terror on special teams while Veikune is getting snaps as a starter in the preseason. Kamerion Wimbley continues to look like Tarzan and play like Jane. Wimbley has all the physical tools but has lacked the aggression and passion to live up to his ability. Rating: B-
Secondary: Young starters Eric Wright and Brandon McDonald were the source of much criticism in the middle of 08 but they bounced back nicely with a solid season. Considering the Browns had little or no pass rush, the secondary’s performance was not bad against the pass. Wright and McDonald will not confuse anyone with Minnifield and Dixon but they are both quality starters. The team added depth by adding Corey Ivy and Hank Poteat. The safety positions will be manned by returning starter Brodney Pool and addition Abram Elam. Pool plays very hard and is willing to stick his head in on any play. His aggression has led to several concussions but he continues to play with the same fervor. The addition of Abram Elam should help against both the run and pass. Elam is a big hitter and loves to play near the line of scrimmage. Rating: B
Special Teams: The best unit on the team is led by veteran kicker Phil Dawson, punter Dave Zastudil and All-Pro return man Josh Cribbs. This unit is one of the best in the league. Dawson is a clutch kicker and serviceable in the kickoff game. Zastudil is a very good punter who can kick in the bad weather in Cleveland. Josh Cribbs is one of the best all around players in the league. He is equally good on kickoff and punt returns. Not only is Cribbs a fantastic return man, he is also a great tackler on special teams. Few if any in modern football have accomplished the feats of Cribbs. Rating: A
Coaching: Eric Mangini had winning seasons in two of his three years with the Jets. Had it not been for the injury to Brett Favre’s arm he would likely still be in New York. Mangini brings attention to detail, aggression and a my way or the highway approach to a team that has lacked discipline for several years. Mangini has ties to Cleveland as he was a former ball boy for the team. He understands the passion and love for Browns football which should serve him well. Offensive coordinator Brian Daboll will have the task of improving an offense that didn’t score a touchdown over the final six games. Improving that should be easy. Daboll will run an offense that is careful and mistake free yet will not be afraid to line up four wide. The defense will be led by Rob Ryan. Ryan is known for his aggression like that of his father Buddy and his twin brother Rob.
Predicted Record: 10-6
Scott Dryden, Senior Staff Writer